link4410 link4411 link4412 link4413 link4414 link4415 link4416 link4417 link4418 link4419 link4420 link4421 link4422 link4423 link4424 link4425 link4426 link4427 link4428 link4429 link4430 link4431 link4432 link4433 link4434 link4435 link4436 link4437 link4438 link4439 link4440 link4441 link4442 link4443 link4444 link4445 link4446 link4447 link4448 link4449 link4450 link4451 link4452 link4453 link4454 link4455 link4456 link4457 link4458 link4459 link4460 link4461 link4462 link4463 link4464 link4465 link4466 link4467 link4468 link4469 link4470 link4471 link4472 link4473 link4474 link4475 link4476 link4477 link4478 link4479 link4480 link4481 link4482 link4483 link4484 link4485 link4486 link4487 link4488 link4489 link4490 link4491 link4492 link4493 link4494 link4495 link4496 link4497 link4498 link4499 link4500 link4501 link4502 link4503 link4504 link4505 link4506 link4507 link4508 link4509 link4510 link4511 link4512 link4513 link4514 link4515 link4516 link4517 link4518 link4519 link4520 link4521 link4522 link4523 link4524 link4525 link4526 link4527 link4528 link4529 link4530 link4531 link4532 link4533 link4534 link4535 link4536 link4537 link4538 link4539 link4540 link4541 link4542 link4543 link4544 link4545 link4546 link4547 link4548 link4549 link4550 link4551 link4552 link4553 link4554 link4555 link4556

Bitcoin Exchanges seeking clarity over levy of GST

Bitcoin Exchanges seeking clarity over levy of GST

Bitcoin Exchanges seeking clarity over levy of GST

MUMBAI: Are Bitcoin exchanges required to pay goods and services tax? If they are, what would the rate be? And, will GST be levied on the revenues or operating margins of these exchanges?

India's top seven Bitcoin exchanges, which include Zebpay, Unocoin, CoinSecure and BtcxIndia, plan to approach the Advance Authority of Ruling (AAR) for clear answers to these questions, two people with direct knowledge of the matter told ET. AAR is a quasi-judicial body that can decide the applicability of tax rates.

"At least one Bitcoin exchange has already filed an application with the Maharashtra AAR for future tax liability," said one of the persons cited above. "The tax department is currently researching the concept as Bitcoins are a very complex subject." Zebpay, Unocoin, CoinSecure and BtcxIndia didn't respond to queries.

For the exchanges, the rate could depend on what the authorities deem Bitcoins to be — goods, services or currency. If Bitcoin is held to be a currency, there will be no GST. If it's a good, then tax of 18% could be levied, and 12% if deemed to be a service.

"The question for many Bitcoin players is whether GST is applicable on the total revenue or on the margins they earn," said Abhishek A Rastogi, partner at law firm Khaitan & Co. "This is mainly because the tax authority must give clarity on whether Bitcoin exchanges are selling goods and services, or are mere trading platforms that earn margins."

AAR DECISION TO DEFINE BIZ MODEL FOR BITCOIN EXCHANGES

According to another government official, who has reviewed the balance sheets of Bitcoin players, their size is quite substantial. "The combined revenue of top seven players would be around Rs 40,000 crore and they operate at about 20% margins," the official said. "In most cases, whenever there is a 'buy' or a 'sell' order on their platforms, these exchanges charge huge differences, in the range of about Rs 1lakh." ..

If that's the case, the indirect tax department could be looking at potential revenue of up to Rs 7,200 crore (if GST is levied at 18%). AAR's decision will also help establish the business model for Bitcoin exchanges in India, defining the category for cryptocurrencies — goods, services or currency.

"The option of proceeding with advance rulings under GST should be exercised to enable clarity on future tax treatment, more so in cases where existing tax positions are untested," said MS Mani, partner, Deloitte India. Industry insiders said Bitcoin players, including Indian exchanges, earn their revenue through commissions, transaction fees, or price-arbitrage opportunities. Most of the exchanges allow trading of various cryptocurrencies besides Bitcoins.

Experts said some Bitcoin exchanges have not been forthcoming with their data and have not paid any sales tax or VAT until now. One of the persons cited above said some exchanges had submitted different revenue figures to the sales tax and VAT authorities. "When we compared the annual results and explanations submitted to the sales tax and VAT authorities, they were diametrically opposite," he said.

Bitcoin is the most popular cryptocurrency that allows online payments between individuals without the involvement of middlemen or financial institutions. Bitcoin prices lost about 4% Thursday evening, and were trading at $14,546 a unit, Coindesk data showed.

 

Author: Sachin Dave ET Bureau|Updated: Jan 05, 2018, 10.30 AM IST

 

Posted By David Ogden Entrepreneur
David ogden cryptocurrency entrepreneur

Alan Zibluk Markethive Founding Member